'Making It' Season 2: Does the Nick Offerman and Amy Poehler show have the most biased judges?

Viewers are of the opinion that the judges don't do much on the show and have been particularly biased towards certain contestants
Nick Offerman (Source : Getty Images)
Nick Offerman (Source : Getty Images)

'Making It' Season 2 is getting interesting all thanks to the challenges that have gone from mildly easy to super challenging. The contestants were given supplies to create welcome wreathes with a twist. Imagine wreaths made of doll legs (creepy much?) and shirt cut-outs. So cool!

And in the second round, they were asked to make oversized front-yard display decor, which Floyd aced thanks to his idea of experimenting with Eagle. Unfortunately, Matt was shown the door. His dragon decor didn't quite impress the judges - Dayna Isom Johnson and Simon Doonan.

But the viewers are of a completely different opinion. They thought the elimination was unfair and that the judges were being biased in their decision.

"@NBCMakingIt please bring different judges on this show. Maybe have different judges every week. The current judges seem to create bias and their logic is irrelevant to the point of the show. #MakingIt #MakeAChange", shared one fan.

Another said, "I legit cannot stand these judges. Everything is fun and cute, and then they come in and it's like the villain in a Disney movie coming to murder a kid because the kid didn't use the right paint at the ball. #MakingIt"

A third fan shared, "It's that time of year again. When #MakingIt comes back on and I have to remind everyone the 2 “special” judges are the worst.''

Well, they have given their verdict. But honestly, Matt's work fell short in comparison to the detailing and grandeur the rest of the contestants had on display.

His dragon was a tad lackluster when pitched against the Eagle installation, pool-noodle surf waves, and a foam boat. However, it was great to see him take the elimination positively.  

In a nutshell, it's being loved by the audiences, with some even labeling it as one of the best reality TV shows to have aired in recent times. A few expressed that most reality shows thrive on gossip, drama, and backbiting, not this one. Well, let's hope 'Making It' continues its glorious stint and gets renewed for another season.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Ellen Pompeo returns as ‘Grey’s Anatomy’ Season 23 brings another emergency to Grey Sloan Memorial.
2026-10-15T18:15:35.000Z
Samuel L. Jackson and Sylvester Stallone reunite in the first teaser for Paramount+’s 'Frisco King.'
2026-10-15T16:46:54.000Z
Sylvester Stallone returns as Dwight Manfredi in 'Tulsa King' Season 4, where rival gangs threaten to change his criminal empire.
2026-10-15T16:18:54.000Z
‘Tulsa King’ takes viewers beyond its namesake city as Dwight Manfredi’s empire grows across seasons. Here's a look at the real-life locations.
2026-10-15T16:02:35.000Z
Hal’s final move at the G7 raises questions about his loyalties as Kate confronts Grace, but keeps the viewers waiting for more.
2026-10-15T15:39:21.000Z
Season 6 of ‘Abbott Elementary’ premiered on October 7, and new guest stars are set to appear in upcoming episodes
2026-10-15T09:31:47.000Z
Linda Cardellini's ‘Crystal Lake’ Episode 1 pays tribute to a real snake killed during ‘Friday the 13th’ filming
2026-10-15T07:17:19.000Z
The adult animated series follows a celebrity escape artist who is pulled back into a war between Apokolips and New Genesis
2026-10-15T07:03:30.000Z
‘Chicago Fire’ Season 15 Episode 2 puts Stella Kidd (Miranda Rae Mayo) and Kelly Severide's marriage to the test after the latter's promotion
2026-10-15T05:26:51.000Z
‘VisionQuest’ introduces a young pickpocket from London whose past traces back to Westview and ties into ‘Agatha All Along’
2026-10-15T05:12:19.000Z