Carrie Underwood’s judging style on ‘American Idol’ might be doing more harm than good — and it’s obvious

We think Carrie Underwood’s time as an ‘American Idol’ contestant might be hurting her judging career
PUBLISHED MAY 12, 2025
Carrie Underwood in a screenshot from 'American Idol' (Cover Image Source: YouTube | American Idol)
Carrie Underwood in a screenshot from 'American Idol' (Cover Image Source: YouTube | American Idol)

Carrie Underwood, the latest judge on the panel of judges of 'American Idol', debuted on the show in 2005, just three years after the first season aired. Underwood went on to win the show at the very young age of 21. This shot up her career, making her the most successful 'American Idol' winner ever, with a record of 16,389,000 sold in her entire career. Fast forward to 2025, and Underwood was brought back to take Katy Perry's place as a judge after her exit.



 

Underwood joined the show and became the only judge on the panel who was an alumnus of the show. This obviously puts Underwood in a special position where she empathizes with the contestants and tries to imagine herself in their shoes. This often makes her hesitant to say no to contestants, as she has even revealed in a tweet she made. However, 'Idol' as a show relies on eliminations for other contestants to progress further.



 

As reported by SKJ Bollywood News, past judges of the show, like Simon Cowell, were more blunt with their approach, which was the driving force of the original 'Idol' show, as audiences loved to see contestants get rejected in the most atrocious ways possible. Since then, Cowell has mended his ways, finally striking a balance between the stark bluntness and appreciation a judge should have for the contestants.


 
 
 
 
 
View this post on Instagram
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

A post shared by Carrie Underwood (@carrieunderwood)


 

As a judge, one can lie on two ends of the spectrum; you can either be a Cowell or an Underwood, but the actual reality lies in between. A good judge needs to be critical when the moment calls for it, without hesitating to appreciate the contestants for their talents. While the other cast of 'Idol' have grown to love Underwood. In an interview with Billboard, Lionel Richie revealed how she felt about Underwood joining the show. "We heard, 'She’s so sweet, so cute,' and we thought we might have a problem with her, because where’s that vicious side?' It wasn’t until she had to say no to a contestant for the first time that things got real. And then she finally had to say no to someone."


 
 
 
 
 
View this post on Instagram
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

A post shared by Lionel Richie (@lionelrichie)


 

Richie recalled the first time Underwood had to say no to a contestant as she said, "Do I have to do this some more?" to which Richie replied, "You’ve got about a hundred more to go." While the 'Idol' cast has been appreciative of Underwood, it's no secret that often times Underwood shrugs off responsibility. One such instance was when judges had to choose between Josh King and Mattie Pruitt, and Underwood simply wheeled her chair away and said, "I have nothing to do with this."

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Samuel Bateman was a self-proclaimed prophet and a member of the Mormon cult of FDLS, in addition to being a polygamist.
4 hours ago
'Dexter: Ressurection,' slated to arrive in October this year, has finally confirmed the arrival of this fan-favorite star who appeared in Season 1.
5 hours ago
'The Boys: Mexico' takes place after the conclusion of the original series' fifth and final season, and will feature supes from outside U.S.A.
5 hours ago
Ahead of its premiere, 'The Boys' revealed new characters making their appearances in the final season, with Ely's Worm as one of them.
7 hours ago
'The Testaments' showmakers were quick to bring back a fan-favorite from the original show 'The Handmaid's Tale.'
8 hours ago
Season 3 of the hit HBO series 'Euphoria' will feature the characters as adults navigating the real world while confronting their past demons.
8 hours ago
However, there is no official indication from Marvel about 'Daredevil: Born Again' Season 2 finale getting a limited theatrical release, but it has a huge possibility.
9 hours ago
The first major character death in 'The Boys' Season opener left fans reeling.
11 hours ago
‘Malcolm in the Middle’ is coming back on Hulu and almost the entire gang is back together
12 hours ago
The third installment of the award-winning series is set five years after the characters graduate from high school.
13 hours ago