'Wheel of Fortune’ contestant misses $68K in Bonus Round — and had no clue what the answer even meant

"Either the puzzles are getting harder or Sony’s losing money," a fan reacted to the bizzare loss.
PUBLISHED JUN 30, 2025
Vanna White and contestant Amy Johnston 'Wheel of Fortune' 2025. (Cover Image Source: YouTube| Wheel of Fortune)
Vanna White and contestant Amy Johnston 'Wheel of Fortune' 2025. (Cover Image Source: YouTube| Wheel of Fortune)

'Wheel of Fortune' contestant Amy Johnston was left fumbling during the Bonus Round because she couldn't guess the correct phrase. The Texas native lost $40,000 and left fans fuming about the bizarre result. Time and again, seasoned viewers of the coveted game show have complained about the senseless puzzles that don't allow contestants to collect grand prizes. During the competition, the Texas native was pitted against Misha Graves, from Minneapolis, Minnesota, and Jon Reinink, from Indianapolis, Indiana. Graves, a mother of seven, took the lead by solving the first two tossups and earning a total of $3,000. The savvy homemaker managed to keep her score up by solving the first puzzle as well, which read out as - “Hula Hoops and Happy Hour." 



 

Johnston made a late entry into the game after solving the tough Mystery Puzzle, which read: “Ice Cream In a Waffle Cone.” The Elvis impersonator who works at a Chinese restaurant continued her winning streak by guessing the letters right on the Prize Puzzle, which read as “Shake off the Winter Blues.” Additionally, she also secured a lavish trip to Lake Tahoe and boosted her earnings to $13,739. Johnston's 'Midas Touch' didn't stop there; she collected an additional $10,000 after guessing all three Triple Toss-Ups and entered the Bonus Round after correctly solving the last puzzle, "Wellness Spa". Johnston made a total of $28,539.

The Johnston Family 'Wheel of Fortune' 2025. (Image Source: YouTube| Wheel of Fortune)
The Johnston Family 'Wheel of Fortune' 2025. (Image Source: YouTube| Wheel of Fortune)

Graves took home $5,000, and the third contestant, Reinink, a minister by trade, earned nothing, so the game gave him a courtesy amount of $1,000. Before moving to the popular Bonus Round, Johnston introduced host Ryan Seacrest to her adorable family backstage. "Got several generations represented here, right?" Seacrest inquired. "Yes, I do. I have my daughter, Kayla. She's my middle child, followed by my husband, Richard, and then my dad. He is the king of dad jokes. Tom," Amy gushed. She then picked the “What are you doing?” category to win $40,000. 

Vanna White and contestant Amy Johnston 'Wheel of Fortune' 2025. (Image Source: YouTube| Wheel of Fortune)
Vanna White and contestant Amy Johnston 'Wheel of Fortune' 2025. (Image Source: YouTube| Wheel of Fortune)

After seeking the standard letters on the puzzle board, which were “R, S, T, L, N, and E,” Johnston picked “G, C, M, and O.” The puzzle board then looked like “_ _ _ _ NG _T O_ER NO_.” “Something is over now,” Johnston made multiple failed attempts at guessing the right answer before the ten-second buzzer could go off. “Picking it over now,” “Making it over now,” “Taking it over now,” “Watching it over now,” “I got nothing,” she lamented in the end. Vanna White then revealed the answer to be “Faxing it over now.” “Of course. I don’t even know what faxing means,” Johnston reacted after Seacrest announced she had lost out on the cash prize.

Ryan Seacrest and contestant Amy Johnston 'Wheel of Fortune' 2025. (Image Source: YouTube| Wheel of Fortune)
Ryan Seacrest and contestant Amy Johnston 'Wheel of Fortune' 2025 (Image Source: YouTube| Wheel of Fortune)

Fans instantly reacted to the foolish puzzle, "Are you kidding me right now? That is 18 losses in a row!!! Are we gonna reach a record-breaking of 20 losses in a row before we finally get a win? I am faxing to WOF right now to wanting to know what is going on!!" a viewer criticized. "Either the puzzles are getting harder or Sony’s losing money," a fan slammed. "Amy was dealt the RAW deal list tonight. That WHAT ARE YOU DOING puzzle was IMPOSSIBLE! The G and O were wasted picks, and she picked them both," a netizen reasoned. 

RELATED TOPICS WHEEL OF FORTUNE

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Steve Carell returns to HBO as a famous author whose attempt to save his daughter pulls him deep into campus chaos.
9 minutes ago
HBO broke its Sunday routine with an early drop, leaving fans staring down a longer wait as a brutal turning point approaches.
3 hours ago
A deadly case pulls Turner from Yosemite to another park, where fire, secrets, and danger collide once again.
6 hours ago
A stunning Trial of Seven reveal leaves viewers emotional, proving 'A Knight of Seven Kingdoms' has real GOT magic.
16 hours ago
The medical drama series is put on hold indefinitely mid-season, allowing 'The Voice' to take over with its revamped 29th season.
22 hours ago
'Grey's Anatomy' Season 22, Episode 11, will air on February 26, introducing two new guest stars
1 day ago
As Miranda Bailey fights to save a critically ill patient and Addison returns to Grey Sloan, fans are eagerly awaiting Episode 11
1 day ago
After evading murder charges himself, Mickey Haller will be back for another season of high-stakes drama with unexpected twists and turns
1 day ago
From the horror-drama series 'IT: Welcome to Derry' to the iconic 'Sex and the City', here are 5 binge-worthy shows to catch this month.
1 day ago
Geneva Robertson-Dworet teases what she has in store for the fan-favorite character Mr. House and his diabolical connection to The Ghoul
1 day ago