Katy Perry asked an 'American Idol' contestant to sing her hit song and instantly regretted it

Emotional damage! Katy Perry threw a tantrum on 'American Idol' after a contestant belted out 'Firework' better than she did
PUBLISHED APR 17, 2025
Screenshots of contestant Sierra Harris and Katy Perry from 'American Idol' 2023 audition episode (Cover Image Source: YouTube| American Idol)
Screenshots of contestant Sierra Harris and Katy Perry from 'American Idol' 2023 audition episode (Cover Image Source: YouTube| American Idol)

Sierra Harris confidently strutted into the 'American Idol' auditions with a ladle for a microphone and yet impressed the judges to earn a golden ticket. "Oh, here we are. Why are you holding a spoon?" Luke Bryan quizzed. Harris explained it was part of her outfit, like a TV prop, and then went on to serenade the judges with her powerful rendition of Heart's 'Barracuda'. However, Katy Perry wanted to test Harris's vocals, so she asked her to sing another song. The judges remained stunned when the Massachusetts native sang a flawless version of Perry's hit song 'Fireworks'. Perry was left gaping as Harris was able to perfectly sync the high notes and tone control. 



 

Perry had earlier complimented the 20-year-old's rock chic vibe, "She looks the part, let's do it, I like the rock stuff all right!" "Wow, it's okay Katy, it's okay honey, it's okay," both Lionel Richie and Bryan tried to console Perry after Harris delivered a power-packed version of her song. "Look, I wanted you to sing Firework because that's a challenging song to say absolutely, and you slayed that I have to squeeze both of my butt cheeks together so hard," Perry reacted. "Some people have to be gimmicky because they can't sing right damn it you can sing and you can sing well," Richie pointed out. 

Katy Perry at Paris Fashion Week - Haute Couture Fall/Winter 2021/2022, on July 05, 2021, in France. (Image Source: Getty Images| Photo by Edward Berthelot)
Katy Perry at Paris Fashion Week - Haute Couture Fall/Winter 2021/2022, on July 05, 2021, in France. (Image Source: Getty Images| Photo by Edward Berthelot)

Perry explained that her first song sounded like a karaoke bar performance, "Your voice is not your party trick anymore, right? Okay, your voice is your purpose," she said, calling out Harris' choice of getting a kitchen ladle to the show. "You know, going back, dialing it back to the 80s and recreating that, it doesn't work, you've got to determine what you want to be okay," Bryan advised on choosing songs relevant to the current time and age. "Just put a fork in the spoon for Hollywood," Perry said in jest before announcing their joint decision to send Harris to Hollywood. Sadly, Harris' journey on 'American Idol' was cut short; she couldn't make it past the Hollywood Week. The young artist announced it with a lengthy Instagram post. 


 
 
 
 
 
View this post on Instagram
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

A post shared by Sierra Harris (@sierralynharris)


 

Calling herself "beyond blessed," she wrote, "Unfortunately, I did not make it past Hollywood week in my idol journey." "This is only the beginning for me… stay tuned to see more of me and my musical career," she added toward the end. Harris released a new single the same year, 'Not Ok' is available on all major streaming platforms. She exclusively told MassLive that he future goals included going on tour and making more music. While appearing on 'The Daniel Taylor Show' last year, Harris recalled the wild moment Perry requested her to sing her song. 



 

The Massachusetts native explained that even though she grew up listening to Perry's songs, her first choice for the audition was according to her singing style. She felt betrayed that the judges did not understand that. "So she asked me to sing her song, and not like I knew her song obviously, but in the moment, like I don't remember almost a single thing I said," she said. Harris continues to grow her musical career with live events and gigs. 

RELATED TOPICS AMERICAN IDOL (2002)

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

‘Masked Singer’ Season 14 is set to celebrate the 30th anniversary of 'Clueless' with a themed episode airing January 21 on FOX
3 days ago
Calla Lily’s emotional performance and personal clues spark intense debate over the celebrity performing behind the mask on ‘The Masked SInger.’
3 days ago
Owl’s strange clues, deep voice, and bird-filled hints on ‘The Masked Singer’ Season 14 have fans circling one big Hollywood comeback name
3 days ago
‘The Masked Singer Season 14 Episode 2 sends fans spiraling over ‘grease’ and ‘patriot’ clues
3 days ago
Shocking reveals shook up 'The Masked Singer' as the Croissants and Le Who Who were finally unmasked in the second season 14 episode
3 days ago
A commanding 'Daily Double' run and a calm 'Final Jeopardy' helped the contestant reach the 'Jeopardy! Champions Wildcard' finals
4 days ago
'Wheel of Fortune' fans argue over the hardest Bonus Round categories, but they largely agree on which ones are easiest to solve
4 days ago
Originally announced in August 2025, 'Love Island: All Stars' Season 3 was set to return on January 14 with iconic Islanders for six weeks
5 days ago
During a Golden Globes commercial break, the host made a major announcement for 'Survivor 50: In the Hands of the Fans'
6 days ago
With the first batch of episodes, the identities of the first set of three traitors and a secret fourth one were eventually revealed
Jan 9, 2026