Is 'Hamilton' the glorification of a racist slave owner? Viewers say real founding fathers were not heroes

'Hamilton' on Disney Plus has led to much debate, as some fiercely argue it's the glorification of a slave owner
PUBLISHED JUL 5, 2020
Lin-Manuel Miranda and Philippa Soo (IMDb)
Lin-Manuel Miranda and Philippa Soo (IMDb)

Those who could not witness the Broadway magic of 'Hamilton' got to see it on Disney Plus. Of course, the floor was opened to heated debate because apart from claiming that the stage-to-screen adaptation of the musical was riddled with historical inaccuracies, others questioned the play itself and asked why the founding father, Alexander Hamilton, was being 'over-glorified', as he himself was a slave trader?

Is this the film you want to present in the wake of the George Floyd protests, they asked. Lin-Manuel Miranda, who acts as Hamilton and is the writer as well, had taken careful precautions to cast people of color in his play, and turning history on its head. The founding fathers in the musical are not white supremacists, but people of color, who deserved an equal say in the founding of America. 

Yet this isn't enough for many. People still seem to be displeased about the musical and have a lot of things to say, as they say that he was a racist. "I’m not saying don’t watch Hamilton because there are many great things in it. I’m just saying be aware of the inaccuracies and the glorification of racist slave owners and if you blindly accept them as heroes, maybe think about why you have been taught that," one wrote.

"So... why is everyone so obsessed with the Hamilton musical? Why in the fuck would we want to celebrate a racist prick?" another tweeted.

"Liberals: Confederate Statues are racist! We cannot celebrate people who defended slavery! Also liberals: Hamilton is just a musical and if you believe everything in it you’re the problem. This is American history." another poked fun at those who had cheered for the destruction of statues, but supported the musical.

"I still love the musical Hamilton, but let's remember the real Alexander Hamilton wasn't an anti-racist, abolitionist hero," another tweeted.

"Take a day off from destroying statues of racist founding fathers to watch Hamilton The Movie about racist founding fathers. No one will notice your hypocrisy," another wrote.

"Enjoy #Hamilton but don’t forget who these men actually were. Know your history behind who these men were before you watch. They may have founded our country, but they were not good people. Racists and slave owners, remember that," one tweeted.

"Hamilton does feel kinda weird this year tho. It’s like, look at the founding fathers but let’s erase their racism and creepiness entirely. Its tough, cuz it slaps," another tweeted.

Others fiercely defended it, and wrote, "I laugh at how people are calling Hamilton racist and problematic. Number 1: you all need to shut the fuck up bc there is so much diversity in cast and the topics are there for a reason. Number 2: it's a musical??? Not that motherfucking deep. Been around for 5 years, RELAX."

'Hamilton' is currently streaming on Disney Plus.

RELATED TOPICS DISNEY+ NEWS DISNEY+

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

The thriller, based on Freida McFadden's bestseller of the same name, enjoyed a solid box office run
7 hours ago
Marvel fans will have to brace for disappointment about the latest on the 'Avengers: Doomsday' trailer
10 hours ago
The full-length trailer charts the rise of Jackson with soundtracks featuring Michael Jackson's iconic hits
10 hours ago
Andy, Miranda, and Emily are back; sharper, more mature, and facing a fashion world that no longer plays by the old rules
22 hours ago
The sequel moved up a week to avoid a horror showdown, throwing Grace into a deadlier game with rival families and no easy exits
23 hours ago
The Wrecking Crew' released on Prime Video on January 28 and has an 86%  Rotten Tomatoes ratings, with the writer already talking about a sequel.
3 days ago
The 'Rambo' prequel will explore John Rambo's early days during the Vietnam War, with 'Sisu' director Jalmari Helander at the helm
3 days ago
Set in Europe, 'The White Lotus' previously confirmed Steve Coogan, Alexander Ludwig, and AJ Michalka as part of the upcoming season's ensemble
3 days ago
The latest comes from a reliable scooper, who breaks down Steve Rogers' role in 'Avengers: Doomsday'
4 days ago
Both 'Avengers' films will see a slew of names return, while some actors reprising their roles remains unclear
4 days ago