'Dancing With The Stars' broke a longtime rule after 32 seasons — but one contestant wasn't happy

After the rule break, the 'Dancing with the Stars' contestant’s manager claimed she'd call '60 Minutes' for an investigation
PUBLISHED APR 3, 2025
Carrie Ann Inaba, Derek Hough, and Bruno Tonioli in a still from 'Dancing with the Stars' season 33 (Cover Image Source: Instagram | Dancing With The Stars )
Carrie Ann Inaba, Derek Hough, and Bruno Tonioli in a still from 'Dancing with the Stars' season 33 (Cover Image Source: Instagram | Dancing With The Stars )

One of the greatest things about 'Dancing with the Stars' has to be seeing your favorite celebrity shake their legs. What makes the show even more engrossing is its well-established rules, meant to promote fairness between contestants. However, in a shocking twist, the show broke an old rule that had been in place since day one. To make matters more tense and dramatic, one of the contestants openly opposed this rule change.

Motsi Mabuse and show host Victoria Swarovski are seen dancing on stage during the 7th Show of
Motsi Mabuse and show host Victoria Swarovski are seen dancing on stage during the 7th Show of 'Let's Dance' at MMC Studios in Cologne, Germany(Image Source: Getty Images | Photo by Andreas Rentz)

For the first time in over 30-plus seasons, 'Dancing with the Stars' made history by revealing the vote count on the September 24, 2024 episode. The dramatic episode saw fashionista Delvey and Beverly Hills, 90210's Tori Spelling eliminated, despite receiving over 14 million fan votes, as per Deadline. This count also holds the record for most votes in a single episode in the show's history. 



 

Additionally, with seven days of viewing across ABC, Disney+, Hulu, and other platforms, the 'Dancing with the Stars' Season 33 premiere reached 7.32 million total viewers with a 1.31 rating in adults 18-49. This also shows a 47% increase in total viewers and a 79% jump in the key demo from its Live+Same Day numbers. Executive producer Conrad Green said he credited the show's multigenerational appeal and social media presence for its longstanding popularity, saying, "We've also been on air long enough now that a new generation of viewers is watching with their kids and the popularity of the show on social apps like TikTok has exploded and introduced new viewers."



 

Fans also shared their opinions about the new development in a Reddit post. A Redditor commented, "This makes sense because we get more votes than we used to," while another stated, "This makes me feel optimistic for the show's future! Was hoping they'd reveal Tori and Anna's placements though, like who was 13th, who was 12th, etc." One user shared, "I do think these random weeks off are going to hurt them. I really think they should have just had it Monday last week instead of two nights this week. It was very early in the season to skip a week. People lose interest fast." Meanwhile, a fan of the show wrote, "I'm surprised they would release the vote total but now I want it broken down."



 

However, not everyone is thrilled with this rule-break. Following Spelling's elimination, her manager, Ruthanne Secunda, asked for a recount, as per Soaps. She said, "I think it's an outrage," while adding, "I'm calling 60 Minutes to do an investigation… definitely a glitch in the system." Secunda further speculated about technical issues, saying, "If airlines can be grounded from a glitch, there could have totally been a glitch in the voting for Tori. I'm suspicious."



 

On the other hand, Spelling supported her manager's concern and said, "Could there be a 'ballroom recount' just to be certain we had the lowest votes?" She further admitted, "I really didn't have a gut instinct that we would be voted off." However, she acknowledged her inexperience, adding, "Listen, I'm a realist. I came into this with no dance experience and I didn’t expect to win the Mirrorball."

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

As it stands, the creators, Duffer Brothers, have denied a return
1 day ago
One Piece' Chapter 1170 is slated to return on January 4, 2026
1 day ago
Simu Liu's 'The Copenhagen Test' is now taking its share of the spotlight ahead of its release
1 day ago
A familiar Cinderella romance gets a modern twist as ‘Bridgerton’ Season 4 quietly reshapes Sophie’s role ahead of Benedict’s long-awaited love story.
1 day ago
Kali’s return in ‘Stranger Things’ Season 5 changes everything, pushing Eleven toward a dark choice and leaving fans questioning her true intentions.
1 day ago
A near-death confession and a surprise ring spark hope for Nancy and Jonathan, until the creators reveal what that emotional moment really means.
1 day ago
'Heated Rivalry' is based on the best-selling 'Game Changers' book series penned by author Rachel Reid
2 days ago
The perilous search for the children in 'Stranger Things 5' Volume 2 turned disastrous as Jonathan and Nancy's lives hung in the balance
2 days ago
Kali's conversation with Eleven has fans speculating who might not survive the finale, as she warns the cycle of experiments will never truly end
2 days ago
The fourth season of 'Bridgerton' is based on the novel 'An Offer From A Gentleman', written by Julia Quinn
2 days ago