'Books of Blood': Fans disappointed with Hulu horror anthology say it 'doesn't feel like Clive Barker'

The film takes a certain amount from Barker’s story titled ‘The Book of Blood’ but thereafter, the other stories seem to have no basis in the books. Naturally, Barker's fans are not happy
Britt Robertson (Screengrab/YouTube)
Britt Robertson (Screengrab/YouTube)

Hulu’s adaptation of Clive Barker’s '80s horror fiction collection, ‘Books of Blood’, is a halfway decent attempt at making a horror anthology film. The movie directed by Brannon Braga, co-written by Braga and Adam Simon, and executive produced by Seth MacFarlane, takes a certain amount from Barker’s first volume — more specifically, the first story titled ‘The Book of Blood’. But thereafter, the other stories seem to have no basis in the books. And all three stories in the horror anthology film are somewhat interconnected. 

The film is visually great. The jump-scares are a few too many to be effective, but they are good jump-scares nonetheless. And two out of the three stories are well-written, even if they don’t take much from the source material. But where the writing fails is the connections are underwhelming and don’t really pay off. In fact, ‘Jenna’ and ‘Miles’, the first two stories, would have gained more had they been feature-length. The last story, ‘Bennet’, was more or less terrible. The film also felt lengthy despite it not really being so, which is a fault of the execution.

But did horror aficionados enjoy this horror feature? The reactions seem mixed, leaning towards negative. Film writer Candice Frederick wrote on Twitter, "I found #BooksOfBlood super disappointing. “Now that the embargo is lifted on #BooksOfBlood I can say I really did not care for it. It's not a bad film but it's very mediocre and forgettable. Worse it doesn't feel like Clive Barker at all. I give it 2 and a half out of 5. Doesn't even feel worth writing a whole review for,” wrote Matt Elliott of HorrorNews on Twitter. More horror fans expressed similar opinions. One Twitter user said, “Well I give #BooksOfBlood a 7/10. It was not bad but it was just lacking any kind of Barker feel to it. On that note, we need a remake of ‘Rawhead Rex’ directed by @panoscosmatos or @RichardStanley7 #MutantFam #horrorcommunity.”

Another Barker fan wrote on Twitter, “BOOKS OF BLOOD OPINION: This was another of Clive's stories turned into a movie that seems to have had little input or influence from him. If you're hoping for something dark, twisted, visionary, this isn't it. This is B Braga doing his interpretation of a horror anthology,” adding, “If it was just a horror movie it would be fine. This had nothing of the atmosphere of CB about it. Nothing.”



 



 



 



 

The obvious reason why people felt the Barker feel was missing was that, for the most part, it wasn’t Barker’s stories. As one fan pointed out, “I'm not sure why you'd ‘adapt’ #clivebarker's BOOKS OF BLOOD just to add your own stories, but as my Horror Movie Month time is limited, I had to abandon @hulu's attempt in favor of anything else. Better luck next time.” Another Twitter user suggested, "Books of Blood would do much better as a series than a movie. There are several volumes of books & a lot of stories. A movie can maybe fit 2."



 



 

‘Books of Blood’ is available on Hulu.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Tom Holland’s ‘Spider-Man: Brand New Day’ adds 10 minutes of unseen footage as fans await ticket sales and showtimes for the film’s return to theaters.
2026-11-17T15:33:01.000Z
Brad Pitt shares ‘Ocean’s 14’ filming is delayed to late 2027, though the original cast praises the script
2026-11-17T10:16:01.000Z
The 'Hunger Game' co-stars Jennifer Lawrence and Josh Hutcherson joined Woody Harrelson and other familiar faces at the New York premiere of 'Sunrise on the Reaping'
2026-11-17T08:24:16.000Z
Christopher Nolan's ambitious retelling of Homer's Greek epic made history at the box office, and fans can now bring it home
2026-11-17T06:31:26.000Z
The film follows a Chicago baker whose dream of owning a business eventually leads to an unexpected reunion
2026-11-17T02:54:46.000Z
Robert Pattinson officially becomes the eighth actor to play James Bond after taking over from Daniel Craig
2026-11-16T15:15:31.000Z
Tamera Mowry-Housley and Kristoffer Polaha reunite for Hallmark’s latest holiday romance
2026-11-16T10:41:50.000Z
The streaming exit comes weeks before HBO's new ‘Harry Potter’ adaptation arrives on Christmas Day
2026-11-16T08:08:46.000Z
James Gunn responds to studio interference rumors surrounding ‘Man of Tomorrow’ following his departure from DC Studios’ leadership.
2026-11-14T17:38:38.000Z
Margot Robbie is set to star in ‘The Week of Pain,’ a new film from A24 and ‘The Drama’ director Kristoffer Borgli.
2026-11-14T02:51:29.000Z