'Bachelor in Paradise': Blake exposes Caelynn for crying wolf after initiating sex with him

Blake Horstmann posted screenshots of his texts with Caelynn during the Stagecoach night and one week prior to the duo appearing on Bachelor in Paradise. 

                            'Bachelor in Paradise': Blake exposes Caelynn for crying wolf after initiating sex with him

Blake Horstmann called out Caelynn Miller Keyes after witnessing her allegations on the recently premiered season 6 of Bachelor in Paradise. And thanks to him revealing the truth, we now know who is exactly to be blamed for the unwanted drama created.

Through what was revealed by Horstmann after the episode aired on Monday night, it is clear that though he might have been at fault for sleeping with two women within a span of 24 hours, the initiation when it came to the night he and Caelynn hooked up was not from him.

But from Caelynn who cried wolf, saying that he slept with her and then began to ghost her prior to their appearance on the reality TV series. 

'Bachelor In Paradise' premiered on Monday night with its brand new season. And right from the start, Blake Horstmann found himself in a puddle after he hooked up with both Kristina and Caelynn within a span of 24 hours during Stagecoach. 

Caelynn then claimed that he called it a mistake and told her to lie about their relationship which she didn't agree to. His problems were increased furtherwhen she accused him of texting Hannah Godwin and Tayshia Adams while he was with her. 


On Tuesday night's episode, Horstmann was confronted by both Kristina and Caelynn. Following the confrontation, he had the entire cast against him with Demi Burnett calling him a loser and Onyeka Ehie calling him the "fu**boy" of the season. 

After the confrontation with both Kristina and Caelynn, Horstmann on camera agreed to the fact that he messed up, and that he didn't know Caelynn was feeling this way. 

Caelynn during her camera interview in the series claimed that Horstmann sweet-talked her and that they were in a relationship. She also accused him of calling her a mistake, that he ghosted her after a few weeks of hooking up and also silenced her.

All this while, we hadn't gotten any information from either of them after Monday's episode. But after Tuesday night's episode and excessive allegation, Blake took to his Instagram account to clear his name after backlash from fans. 

"With all of that said, I want to get the truth out. I was not able to defend myself down in Paradise because me and most of the beach had no idea the things Caelynn was saying in her interviews. I NEVER 'sweet talked' her at Stagecoach. Caelynn and I were NEVER in a relationship. I NEVER ghosted Caelynn, I NEVER called her a mistake and I absolutely NEVER EVER EVER silenced Caelynn. I never expected to have to do something like this, but after finally seeing the episodes I feel like I have no other choice but to release the text exchanges between her and myself," Horstmann posted on his Instagram account. 

Blake Horstmann revealed the text messages exchanged between him and Caelynn during the stagecoach.

He went on to add that she had his empathy for the trauma she has faced, referring to the rape that took place when she was in college. But he wasn't going to sit down quietly, as the harmful accusations were too much. 

Horstmann later posted screenshots of his texts with Caelynn during the Stagecoach night a week prior to the duo appearing on Bachelor in Paradise. 

The texts show that the person who Horstmann claims to be Caelynn tells him to “loosen up” saying, “Let’s just have a good time man.” Blake replied saying, “We can cuddle, but no sex,” to which she answered, “Yes sex. Only sex. No cuddling.” Later, adding, “If I come over it’s strictly for sex. Nothing more nothing less.”

With the Stagecoach texts ending there, the next set of messages are a week before they left for Bachelor in Paradise, where Caelynn tells Horstmann “Dude. I’m shaking. Who knows? And how? We’ve been so careful. What happened?

Blake Horstmann revealed texts between him and Caelynn a week before Bachelor in Paradise. (Instagram)

Horstmann responded that he wanted to “tell (before Paradise) so that she isn’t crazy mad when she is down there” .Though we don't know who he is talking about, it is speculated that it might be Kristina. Because on Tuesday's episode she revealed that Horstmann told her about him and Caelynn a wee before Bachelor in Paradise. 

Through all these texts one thing is clear - Caelynn just stirred up unwanted drama that has gotten her into a major soup right now. Not just with Horstmann but with the series fans as well. These texts if they are from Caelynn clearly show that she was the one who initiated the sex that night even though Horstmann wasn't up for it. And that he did not ghost her or call her a mistake. These texts also prove that even though Horstmann had the intention to tell it was Caelynn who was in two minds.

Blake Horstmann uploaded a story on Instagram revealing texts exchanged between him and Caelynn. (Instagram)

Though a few fans on Twitter still claim that Caelynn is in the right, most fans claim that if Caelynn was purely searching for sex then Horstmann is not to be blamed. "If the situation were reversed, blake a woman & caelynn a man, they'd be calling caelynn out for slut shaming. Blake was a single guy, and caelynn was actively seeking him out purely for sex. #BachelorInParadise," said a fan. 

While another added, "we rlly let caelynn trick us into thinking that she was this perfect angel and that hannah b was the insane one and then we watched her do the exact same thing to blake #BachelorInParadise." 

"Yoooooo so now Blake still isn't Prince Charming, but Caelynn is turning out to be craaaazyyyyyy...," wrote another fan. 

If you have an entertainment scoop or a story for us, please reach out to us on (323) 421-7515