'American Song Contest': Fans say Jewel's song sounded 'Eurovisiony in a 2007 way'

'I dont want to sound mean but the song was way over produced,' one of the comments read
Jewel from Alaska on 'American Song Contest' (NBC)
Jewel from Alaska on 'American Song Contest' (NBC)

Jewel was one of the much-awaited contestants on Week 3 of 'American Song Contest' and the Alabama singer's 'The Story' had fans dishing out mixed reviews. Although Jewel kept it simple, the fans felt the track was overproduced and weren't thoroughly impressed.

This week's contestants include — Ni/Co (Alabama), Riker Lynch (Colorado), Nitro Nitra (Delaware), Ale Zabala (Florida), Brittany Pfantz (Louisiana), Brooke Alexx (New Jersey), Sabyu (Northern Mariana Islands), Jesse LeProtti (South Carolina), Judd Hoos (South Dakota), Tyler Braden (Tennessee) and Grant Knoche (Texas).

READ MORE

'American Song Contest': Fans say Tennessee must advance, 'if Montana can, so can Tyler Braden'

'American Song Contest' Week 3: Twitter says Alabama's Ni/Co's 'beginning was lackluster'



 

"Unpopular opinion - the Jewel song was not great (she’s had better) and New York was a good performance of a mediocre song and deserved not to move on. #AmericanSongContest," one of the tweets read. Another fan was in agreement. "Song 7 - Show 3 Alaska — Jewel — “The Story” i dont want to sound mean but the song was way over produced it sound like something from the early 80's My score - 3."

"I think Katy Perry's version of that song is better than Jewel's #AmericanSongContest," one of the fans opined. Some felt it was very euorvision. "Credit to Jewel for somehow having the most Eurovisiony song of the #AmericanSongContest so far," one of the tweets read. "Jewel's song and staging feel like what would happen if a classic Eurovision song got a modern staging #AmericanSongContest," another fan commented. "Jewel's song for Alaska sounds so Eurovisiony in a 2007 way and I kinda dig it #americansongcontest," a tweet said.

For those unaware, "Fun fact: Jewel was a judge on the 4th season of a cappella singing competition show "The Sing Off". Colton of Ni/Co was a contestant on the 2nd season. #AmericanSongContest," a tweet said. "Jewel song sounds like a Jewel Song mixed with Katy Perry Firework. I actually really love Jewel's pop album 0304 it's my third favorite album by her. Thos isn't 0304 caliber pop and not her pocket folk. Just ok. #americansongcontest,": a fan opined. Here's a final verdict: "I love you Jewel but that song was ass #AmericanSongContest,"



 



 



 



 



 



 



 



 



 

'American Song Contest' airs on Monday, at 8/7c on NBC. You can vote for your favorite performances on the NBC website, the NBC app and TikTok. You can also stream your favorite artists' songs on your preferred music streaming app.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Mary Camden, aka Jessica Biel, talks about the storylines and the safe set she wants around the Camdens
2026-10-26T09:57:21.000Z
The show has adapted two of Jack Carr's novels so far, and the third book sends Reece to a ranch
2026-10-26T09:14:16.000Z
Show creator Erin Foster explains how her own marriage could shape Joanne and Noah’s future
2026-10-26T05:32:46.000Z
‘Tracker’ welcomes Brian Stepaneck, known for his work on Disney Channel, in its latest episode
2026-10-26T04:57:18.000Z
After Cal finds a lead, the team is sent to investigate the potential threat, ending with a dangerous cliffhanger.
2026-10-26T04:29:43.000Z
Eddie and Susie plan a casino in the Middle East as the Netflix series returns with a changed cast.
2026-10-24T16:38:18.000Z
An unanswered call sends Sean’s girlfriend to the precinct after news of a police shooting.
2026-10-24T14:03:15.000Z
In an exclusive interview, Donnie Wahlberg shares whether Tom Selleck is open to working in ‘Boston Blue’
2026-10-24T08:19:19.000Z
‘Fire Country’ welcomes a Grammy-winning artist to Smokey's in their latest episode
2026-10-24T06:24:48.000Z
Episode 3 of ‘Sheriff Country’ delves deeper into Eva Santos's (Rachel Ticotin) past
2026-10-24T05:05:00.000Z