'American Idol' fans furious over 'Cougars for Colin' crowd sign for 18-year-old country singer Colin Stough

Colin Stough has made it to 'American Idol's Top 12, but here's why fans are 'disgusted'
UPDATED APR 28, 2023
'American Idol' fans furious at Colin Stough's treatment on TV (ABC)
'American Idol' fans furious at Colin Stough's treatment on TV (ABC)

BRENTWOOD, CALIFORNIA: After observing Colin Stough, a contestant who recently turned 18, being treated in a "disgusting" manner, 'American Idol' viewers have taken offense at the program. Before his performance, a woman held up a placard that said, "Cougars For Colin," which annoyed the audience at home.

Colin has made it to 'American Idol's Top 20, and after getting the news, he stepped to the stage to sing his own rendition of Parker McCollum's 'Pretty Heart'. The enormous screens behind him displayed a rural environment bathed in the light of a colorful set, replete with rolling clouds, during his time on stage. Colin stood in the center of the stage, playing his guitar, as Luke Bryan sang along from the judge's chair. Colin is always true to his roots and portrays his actual self on stage, according to fellow judge Katy Perry. While she acknowledges that honesty is valued on Idol, she goes on to state that she would want to see Colin shine with greater vocal power and risks.

RELATED ARTICLES

'American Idol' viewers slam Lucy Love for 'angry' expressions, urge singer to 'show gratitude'

'Bring back two eliminations a week': 'American Idol' voting system slammed as several contestants exit



 

'I about crawled out of my skin'

On April 23, Colin reached the Top 20 and had another performance after reaching the Top 12. Prior to singing a rendition of Parker McCollum's song 'Pretty Heart', a woman was seen in the audience holding up a placard just before Colin began to perform. It said, "Cougars for Colin," and the woman was grinning broadly.

Despite the fact that the camera moved to the audience several times during his performance, the placard was never seen again. Fans of 'American Idol' were outraged when they noticed a banner in the audience stating that Colin had only recently turned 18. "Not my normal post but…. Watching American Idol and I’m sorry 'COUGARS FOR COLIN?!' He literally like just turned 18," one fan said on Twitter. "Did yall see the "Cougars for Colin" sign? lol #AmericanIdol #IdolTop20Reveal," someone else asked.



 



 

On Youtube, one comment read, "I'm still tripping about the Cougars for Colin sign." one fan asked, "Did that lady really have a Cougars for Colin sign?" While another chimed in, "Why would they let that fan have a Cougars For Colin sign? He literally just turned 18."

Katy Perry (C) and Luke Bryan (R) praise Colin Stough (L) (ABC)
Katy Perry (C) and Luke Bryan (R) praise Colin Stough (L) (ABC)

'Brad Pitt of country music'

The 18-year-old, who made it to the Top 12, blew the judges away with his performance of Robyn's 'Dancing on My Own' on April 24. Luke ran up to the stage and hugged him as soon as he completed the song. Luke and Katy freely shared their pride in watching Colin improve in the competition in a group interview following the episode.

"Colin made me a believer. I was a little big on the edge," Katy said. "It didn't real knock it out of the park for me, and then what he did tonight with the Robyn song was one of the best performances of the whole night." She added, "He really sealed his deal. It only took a different moment. I think he literally turned his life around. He's the Brad Pitt of country music. He's got the taste and the song choice and the vocal ability — he really showcased it tonight," as per People.

Meanwhile, Luke discussed how he can relate to contestants such as Colin. "When I get a country kid like Colin, I can see myself in him," he explained. "On the show last night, I really, really challenged him to be more aggressive with that mentality. He went out there, and he did a great job."

'American Idol' Season 21 airs every Sunday and Monday at 8 pm ET on ABC.

This article contains remarks made on the Internet by individual people and organizations. MEAWW cannot confirm them independently and does not support claims or opinions being made online.

RELATED TOPICS AMERICAN IDOL (2002)

GET THE BIGGEST CELEBRITY & ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Serving as creators are 'Billions' co-creators Brian Koppelman and David Levien
2 hours ago
The 11-episode season premieres January 21, 2026 and can be streamed on Hulu and Disney+
5 hours ago
McDermitt will be part of a storyline surrounding a new recurring cast member, Alona Tal.
8 hours ago
The Academy Award winner has been missing from the small screen since his 'Yellowstone' exit
10 hours ago
'Heated Rivalry' Episode 3 brings a new romance to the ice and a secret that could shake everything in the show
10 hours ago
HBO's new series, 'Heated Rivalry', follows two rival hockey players who end up falling in love
11 hours ago
On the lawless frontier, two unstoppable women clash over land, love, and survival and no one will emerge unscathed.
13 hours ago
A flyer to the musical, 'Oklahoma!', in a 'Stranger Things' Season 5 episode may be connected to Venca's origin story
14 hours ago
A desperate rescue plan collides with a dangerous cartel uprising and Kingstown may not survive the fallout.
15 hours ago
LEGO dropped a highly detailed 2,593-piece Creel House from ‘Stranger Things’, and while collectors love the design, the price has everyone talking
15 hours ago