'American Idol' fans slam 'troublemaker' Nutsa's 'gimmicky' apology to Katy Perry over duet-round fiasco

Despite Nutsa's efforts to reconcile with everyone, fans continued to criticize her, urging her to tone down the drama
UPDATED APR 10, 2023
'American Idol' contestant Nutsa apologizes to judge Katy Perry (ABC)
'American Idol' contestant Nutsa apologizes to judge Katy Perry (ABC)

LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA: Nutsa faced the judges on the Sunday, April 9, episode of 'American Idol,' following her drama-filled duet round. Despite her efforts to reconcile with everyone, fans criticized her, urging her to tone down the drama.

Nutsa, a contestant from Dubai, was paired with Carina DeAngelo in last week's Duet Round, which aired on April 3. Carina became concerned throughout the practice process since she and Nutsa were visibly unprepared for their performance, but Nutsa chose to sleep. Carina had to call Nutsa and ask her to come down from her room in order to attend a singing session with the coaches. Nutsa eventually advanced to the following round, while Carina did not. The viewers were harsh on Nutsa, with many accusing her of being selfish and hurting Carina's chances of advancement.

READ MORE

'American Idol' Season 21: Kaeyra wows judges with electrifying performance as she vies for 'Top 24' spot

Why did Kaya Stewart quit 'American Idol'? Season 21 contestant's exit leaves Katy Perry in tears



 

Nutsa apologizes to judges

During Showstoppers Pt 1, Nutsa discusses how the duets round was the most emotional event of her life. "It was really hurtful to me…I never do bad to people," she claims. "After I left that stage, I was just destroyed." Katy's instruction to have "more Grace" upset her. She apologizes to the judges in her final ruling for the event. Katy and Nutsa hug and the former compliments Nutsa on her "wonderful" apologies. Katy expresses her admiration for Nutsa's tenacity.

Nutsa sang 'Proud Mary'. Katy describes her performance as "so spectacular" to Nutsa. "You whipped your hair in the camera more times than JLo," Katy tells Nutsa. "We didn’t put you in the Top 24….You did," Katy adds. Nutsa is obviously bewildered by the embarrassing fake-out. However, she advanced to the next round.

'Can’t believe American Idol keeps putting her through'

Viewers who were shocked at seeing Nutsa advancing, a person wrote on Twitter, "Nutsa is not my fav. So many other singers were better IMO." A second person wrote, "#nutsa screwed her duet partner, then played the innocent victim… no fan here." One Twitter user wrote, "I dont care for Nutsa one bit. You can put her through to the lives, she wont get a vote for me. She doesnt feel authentic and i dont care for her." While a fan felt that even though Nutsa can sing, the apology on TV was too much. They wrote, "Nutsa can carry a tune but kill the gimmicks."



 



 



 



 

Calling her performance a hot mess, a fan wrote, "That version of Proud Mary by Nutsa was a hot mess and I'm surprised they put her through." Another person quipped, "Nutsa is going to be a troublemaker and I’m here for it!" While labeling her a narcissist, another fan added, "#nutsa is a narcissist and I can’t believe American Idol keeps putting her through ~ she better not win. She gaslit her duet partner and the world, apparently." While one viewer tweeted, "NUTSA IS THE EPITOME OF CRAP."



 



 



 



 

'American Idol' Season 21 airs every Sunday and Monday at 8 pm ET on ABC.

This article contains remarks made on the Internet by individual people and organizations. MEAWW cannot confirm them independently and does not support claims or opinions being made online.

RELATED TOPICS AMERICAN IDOL (2002)

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Jessica Jones and Matt Murdock were last seen together on the one-season crossover 'Defenders' on Netflix
7 hours ago
The dedication towards the end highlighted how deeply Diego Borella's loss was felt across the production team
7 hours ago
Aileen Wuornos' haunting tale had been previously depicted in the 2003 film 'Monster' starring Charlize Theron
7 hours ago
‘Pluribus’ Season 1 finale ramps up the suspense as Carol faces tough moral choices and Manousos arrives, with fans eagerly awaiting the conclusion
10 hours ago
Fans were soon disappointed when they tuned in on December 18 for a new 'Matlock' Season 2 episode but found none.
10 hours ago
Created by Darren Star, Season 5 shifts its focus to Emily’s romance with Marcello, leaving fans questioning Gabriel's place in her story
11 hours ago
The new 'Pluribus' fan theory stems from a scene in which Carol is seen driving around town in a police car
13 hours ago
Carol continued to research the Hive Mind in the latest episode of 'Pluribus', uncovering deeper insights about the Joining
14 hours ago
The singer released the first two episodes of new docuseries about the Eras Tour last week
1 day ago
The show tracing the sleuth's early years releases March 4, 2026 with all episodes dropping together
1 day ago