'All American' season 2: Spencer James is still in two minds, but fans want him to choose Coach Billy Baker

It is an incredibly difficult choice for Spencer James on 'All American' as he has something to lose on each side.
PUBLISHED OCT 8, 2019

The review contains spoilers from 'All American' Season 2 Episode 1 — 'Hustle & Motivate'.

The second season of 'All American' premiered on October 7 on The CW and Spencer James (Daniel Ezra)  finds himself at a crossroads as he had to choose between staying in Beverly Hills and playing with Coach Billy Baker (Taye Diggs) or joining his father Corey James (Chad L. Coleman) at South Crenshaw High, where he has been selected as the new coach.

It is an incredibly difficult choice for Spencer as he has something to lose on each side. After winning the state championship at Beverly Hills, he is the star footballer and already has a crazy fan following. Moreover, he has his girlfriend Layla (Greta Onieogou), his friends and better facilities too. If he chooses to go back to Crenshaw High, he will have to forget everything and start from scratch. But, if he chooses Beverly Hills, he won't be able to help his dad and his best friend Coop (Bre-Z). 

His second family, Laura (Monét Mazur), Jordan (Michael Evans Behling) and Olivia (Samantha Logan) also miss him as much as his real family, Grace James (Karimah Westbrook) and Dillon (Jalyn Hall). But, his mother has always been understanding and knows that being in Beverly Hills opens a new world of opportunities for him. In the scene when she gets to know his dad has asked him to come and join his team in Crenshaw, she is almost about to discuss it but gets an important phone call and has to rush.



 

Moreover, with Coach Baker thinking of quitting the team, things are way too complicated. By the end of the first episode titled 'Hustle & Motivate', Spencer does come back to the Baker House and Olivia jumps with joy and gives him a big hug. Everybody is celebrating but Spencer knows he has to pick one side. 

The decision is still pending until the last scene when Spencer texts his dad: "Need more time with my decision. Hope you understand." Fans clearly want Spencer to be with the Bakers. One user posted, "Spencer has a big decision to make and Billy is looking to make serious changes when All American finally returns tonight for Season 2!" and another one wrote, "Let me be the first to say to hell with Spencer's dad after this ending."

One fan even went on to tweet: "So before we get into this new All American, do y’all think Spencer’s dad is trying to use him? Cause I do #AllAmerican." As the new episode rolls out on Monday, October 14, on The CW, there is much at stake for Spencer, however, there's hope he might choose to stay in Beverly Hills. 

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

The steamy hockey romance behind 'Heated Rivalry' is suddenly hard to find, as fans race to read Shane and Ilya's story before Season 2 arrives
57 minutes ago
Brittany Snow, who portrays Sophie O'Neil in the show, gave fans a sneak peek at the upcoming drama in 'The Hunting Wives' Season 2
1 hour ago
CBS had initially planned to release 'NCIS,' 'NCIS: Origins', and 'NCIS: Sydney' in February
2 hours ago
The focus is on a new breed of villains set to be quite the challenge for Monkey D. Luffy
13 hours ago
The series is based on Alice Feeney’s 2020 novel of the same name and ended on a gripping note
14 hours ago
The star of the hit Apple TV show dropped a major update on the comedy series' new season
16 hours ago
Despite the snub, Hudson Williams and Connor Storrie represented 'Heated Rivalry' at the 2026 Golden Globes, just not in the way fans hoped
18 hours ago
A chilling revelation in Episode 3 changes everything for Jonathan Pine (and the fans) in ‘The Night Manager’ Season 2
18 hours ago
One shocking decision upends Tommy’s future as a violent confrontation leaves lives, and loyalties, hanging in the balance.
18 hours ago
The six-part thriller is developed by William Oldroyd and was released on Thursday, January 8, but the fans are questioning its origin
18 hours ago