'Shocked they cut her': Fans upset as 'American Idol' judges eliminate stripper mom Fire Wilmore

'American Idol' fans were confused to see Fire Wilmore's elimination after she amassed praises from judges initially
UPDATED APR 10, 2023
'American Idol' fans were disappointed at Fire's elimination and slamned judges for giving her standing ovation initially (ABC)
'American Idol' fans were disappointed at Fire's elimination and slamned judges for giving her standing ovation initially (ABC)

LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA: The survivors of Hollywood Week on 'American Idol' had no time to recuperate as they took the stage for the Showstoppers round. Before the all-important Final Judgment, contestants had to impress Katy Perry, Lionel Richie and Luke Bryan. They performed in front of an audience, accompanied by a band. After their performance, the contestants met with the judges to find out if they had advanced to the next round.

In a tragic turn of events, fans were forced to say goodbye to this season's most talked-about contestant, Fire Wilmore, and they are not happy about it. Most took to Twitter to criticize both the judges and the show's creators, questioning why they would hype a contestant so much, only to eliminate her later.

RELATED ARTICLES 

'Put this Fire out already': 'American Idol' fans accuse producers of using stripper mom as 'cliffhanger'

'Hard NO': 'American Idol' fans furious as judges put stripper mom Fire through after 'weak' performance

Fire met with the judges to hear about her chances in the competition. "You have grown faster, maybe than we thought," Katy told the single mother. "You have fought tooth and nail," she added. 

Fire informs Katy that she has grown faster than they expected. Katy, she believes, is on her side. All the judges think she has potential. Her duet partner, Kaya Stewart, had to withdraw from the competition due to illness. Her stage presence is strong, but she has some difficulties in the higher registers. She needs more experience, but she has what it takes.

"We have learned from you," Luke said. However, she is not advanced to the following round. "It's the end of the American Idol journey," Katy told Fire. "But truthfully, your fire is never going out," she added. 

Despite the young mother's progress, Fire will not be moving on to the Top 24. "I'm not OK with going home," Fire exclaimed.

'NEVER been more disappointed with American Idol'

Calling out the makers of show and the judges, a fan wrote, "I have NEVER been more disappointed with American Idol. They gave Fire a standing ovation on her Showstopper performance. So, WHY? and WTF were they thinking? If anyone deserved to be in the Top 24, it is Fire! Please reconsider and make it a Top 25???" Another person asked, "How did I KNOW #AmericanIdol wouldn't end up choosing Fire after ALL THAT TIME telling her story..." Another chimed in, "shock they cut her after giving fire so much tv time .. #americanidol .. dont think its over yet." Calling her the season's main character, a fan wrote, "I know she’s super hyped up as this season’s main character for some reason but Fire just is not good. Sorry. She sounds so plain. Not a performance of hers I’ve enjoyed much. I know they’ll keep her on as long as they can but there’s so many better contestants."



 



 



 



 

During her performance, a fan guesse, "be big shock if they reject fire #americanidol so much tv time." Speaking of how she deserved more, a fan tweeted, "Fire is a feel good story and shes definitely grown.... She persevered and she should be proud of herself. But shes another one im not shocked to see go home. And her response to being sent home was disappointing. Should be more appreciative, but." Another fan said, "EXHIBIT #1. FYRE SHOULDNT HAVE GOTTEN PAST THE PRELIMINARY AUDITION YET THEY WANTED A SOB STORY ON THE SHOW. STRIPPER OR NOT U GOTTA BE ABLE TO SING. SIMON WOULD NEVER #AMERICANIDOL #IDOL #IDOLTOP24"



 



 



 

This article contains remarks made on the Internet by individual people and organizations. MEAWW cannot confirm them independently and does not support claims or opinions being made online.

RELATED TOPICS AMERICAN IDOL (2002)

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Warwick Davis, one of the returning characters shared that the series remains faithful to books
16 hours ago
Matt Duffer didn't seem too confident about their chances as he weighed on the emotional finale
17 hours ago
Netflix show's faithful believe in one explanation that has been doing the rounds
17 hours ago
From Cooper's fiancee to TL Norris, we look at names likely to kick the bucket in season 2
18 hours ago
HBO Max dropped off a 90-second teaser of episode 1 to set the tone for what to expect
20 hours ago
Netflix teases an early surprise for ‘Bridgerton’ fans, unlocking Season 4’s first episode weeks ahead through a global masquerade livestream.
1 day ago
Ryan Condal hints at a defined endgame for ‘House of the Dragon,’ teasing that the Targaryen saga may be closer to its final act than fans expect.
1 day ago
Fans spot a chilling season one Easter egg that appears to foreshadow ‘Stranger Things’ dark and divisive finale.
1 day ago
A familiar face from Grey’s Anatomy’s earliest days returns in season 22, hinting at major fallout and unresolved history
1 day ago
'Stranger Things' finally wrapped up it's ten year saga on Netflix, however few questions remain unanswered
1 day ago