Why was Rex Heuermann called 'Peter'? Gilgo Beach serial killer's colleagues nicknamed him after 'Family Guy' character

Rex Heuermann's colleague described him to be 'really friendly and really nice'
UPDATED JUL 18, 2023
Rex Heuermann who was arrested in connection to the Gilgo Beach murders was nicknamed after 'Family Guy' character 'Peter' (RH Consultants and Associates, IMDb)
Rex Heuermann who was arrested in connection to the Gilgo Beach murders was nicknamed after 'Family Guy' character 'Peter' (RH Consultants and Associates, IMDb)

LONG ISLAND, NEW YORK: Gilgo Beach murder suspect Rex Heuermann's colleagues nicknamed him after the sitcom 'Family Guy' character 'Peter Griffin'. The 59-year-old architect who is 6 feet 4, and weighs about 240 pounds has a striking resemblance to the popular animated character, according to his colleagues.

The architect who runs his own firm RH Consultants and Associates founded in 1994 was arrested for the alleged killings of Amber Costello, Melissa Barthelemy, and Megan Waterman, and is considered a prime suspect in the death of the 'Gilgo Four' who is identified as Maureen Brainard-Barnes. The triple-murder suspect pleaded not guilty to three counts of murder in the first degree and three counts of murder in the second degree, according to New York Post.

(L-R) Amber Costello, Megan Waterman, Melissa Barthelemy, and Maureen Brainard-Barnes (Fox 5 New York/YouTube screengrab)
(L-R) Amber Costello, Megan Waterman, Melissa Barthelemy, and Maureen Brainard-Barnes (Fox 5 New York/YouTube screengrab)

Why was Rex Heuermann called 'Peter'?

A former colleague of Heuermann with whom he worked for almost 20 years said, "We called him ‘Peter,’ the ‘Family Guy,’ mostly because of the way he looked — he was goofy." The New York-based architect who asked not to reveal his name said was shocked to learn the married father of two's alleged connection with the serial killings. He described Heuermann as " really friendly and really nice."

"A year ago, my wife was watching a documentary about [the case], telling me how [a] guy was out there killing all these girls on Long Island. I could have never imagined this. It’s like ‘The Twilight Zone,' " he added.

The alleged killer was likely 'very cruel to certain people'

In 2011, CBS show 'Criminal Minds' producer and former FBI profiler Jim Clemente described the person behind the unsolved killings as an intelligent, educated, and mild-mannered "sexual sadist" who is likely to enjoy watching people suffer. 

"He shows this mask, this cover of kindness, so he can continue to commit his crimes. He’s incredibly good at compartmentalizing, separating his murders from his family life," said Clemente who added that the killer may have been "very cruel to certain people."

A former colleague of the suspect said a friend in Atlanta sent him a story link about the Gilgo Beach murders and asked if he knew the alleged killer. "And I’m like, 'What the f**k? I do know him,' When I saw this whole thing unfold, I was in shock. How was this even possible? It’s crazy. His contact is literally in my phone," he said. The man shared that he first met Heuermann in 2003 at the company Mojo Stumer where the suspect worked as a consultant. "He was always pretty patient with me. He taught me how to navigate through the city’s building code," he recalled.

RELATED TOPICS GILGO BEACH MURDERS REX HEUERMANN

MORE STORIES

Before his shocking arrest, Manuel Rocha served under both Democratic and Republican administrations during his 25-year diplomatic career
Dec 4, 2023
Conflicting accounts emerged regarding the authorities' awareness, prompting a demand for a $1M settlement for William Vannasap's injuries
Dec 3, 2023
Annette Pershal was shot multiple times with a pellet gun and her injuries were non-survivable, said authorities
Dec 2, 2023
Christina Riggs became the 18th woman in the US to be executed and was the youngest woman to be put to death at just 28
Dec 2, 2023
A fire, initiated posthumously, has raised suspicions as Griffiths was found shot but the autopsy showed no signs of smoke inhalation
Dec 2, 2023
As per the lawsuit, Gabby Petito's parents allege that Brian Laundrie's parents knew about their daughter's death along with the location of the crime
Dec 2, 2023
Jeremy is 5’11, weighs 245 lbs., has brown hair that is greying, green eyes and a greying beard
Dec 1, 2023
Jovannie Vega is accused of picking up the little boy and slamming him down onto the floor multiple times
Dec 1, 2023
'I feel bad for the families because I know exactly what they're going through,' said Mark Jacobo, whose son was killed in a firearm incident
Dec 1, 2023