Who is Cara Rintala? Massachusetts woman on fourth murder trial for strangling wife to death

The murder took place in March 2010 and Cara Rintala was indicted for her wife's murder in October 2011
UPDATED SEP 13, 2023
Cara Rintala has been charged with first-degree murder of her wife (WWLP News Screengrab)
Cara Rintala has been charged with first-degree murder of her wife (WWLP News Screengrab)

NORTHAMPTON, MASSACHUSETTS: Cara Rintala, a name synonymous with a decade-long legal war topped the headlines for being the first Massachusetts woman to face murder charges in the death of her wife in 2010.

Rintala has returned to the spotlight as she now prepares for her fourth murder trial on the first-degree murder charges that were twice called a mistrial, reported Law and Crime.

Who was Cara Rintala's wife?

.
Annamarie Cochrane-Rintala was allegedly murdered by her wife in their shared home (WWLP News Screengrab)

Rintala's wife Annamarie Cochrane-Rintala's body was discovered at the bottom of their basement staircase.

First responders found her blood-soaked and beaten-up body which was covered in paint.

At the time, a medical examiner determined that the 37-year-old woman was strangled to death. 

On March 29, 2010, Rintala was found cradling her dead wife in the basement of the home she shared with Annamarie. Both the women were found covered in fresh white paint.

.
Cara Rintala and Annamarie Cochrane-Rintala lived together in their home in Massachusetts (WWLP News Screengrab)

There were also signs of manual strangulation on the victim's body.

Why was Cara Rintala's conviction overturned?

.
Cara Rintala's 2016 conviction was overturned (Narragansett Police Department)

Rintala who has consistently maintained innocence was indicted for her wife's murder on October 19, 2011.

After several legal twists in the case, the 56-year-old woman's 2016 conviction was overturned by the state’s Supreme Judicial Court citing erroneous evidence.

Rintala initially told investigators that the night before the responders found the dead body, she had been arguing with her wife and also acknowledged her status as the "number one suspect."

However, the investigation took a different turn when surveillance footage from a McDonald's restaurant showed Rintala disposing of items in a trash can.

Among the items recovered from the trash were three rags. One of the items appeared to have a faint bloodstain.

However, the bloodstain could not be linked to Annamarie.

When is Carla Rintala's fourth murder trial?

.
Cara Rintala faces first-degree murder charges in the death of her wife Annmarie Rintala (Court TV)

A decade after the tragic incident unfolded and her conviction was overturned, the decision cast doubt on the validity of the previous trials which necessitated a new one.

Rintala's fourth murder trial began on Wednesday, September 13. She was living with her teenage daughter and her elderly parents in the Plantation State following the murder.

The trial is expected to be conducted for three to four weeks.

Hampshire Superior Court Judge Richard Carey ordered to release her without objection from the state and she was released on $50,000 personal surety and &50,000 cash bail, according to Law and Crime.

The prosecution in the case will be led by Steven E George,  the Northwestern First Assistant District Attorney while Rintala is being represented by Boston attorney Rosemary Scapicchio.

RELATED TOPICS MASSACHUSETTS NEWS

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Before his shocking arrest, Manuel Rocha served under both Democratic and Republican administrations during his 25-year diplomatic career
Dec 4, 2023
Conflicting accounts emerged regarding the authorities' awareness, prompting a demand for a $1M settlement for William Vannasap's injuries
Dec 3, 2023
Annette Pershal was shot multiple times with a pellet gun and her injuries were non-survivable, said authorities
Dec 2, 2023
Christina Riggs became the 18th woman in the US to be executed and was the youngest woman to be put to death at just 28
Dec 2, 2023
A fire, initiated posthumously, has raised suspicions as Griffiths was found shot but the autopsy showed no signs of smoke inhalation
Dec 2, 2023
As per the lawsuit, Gabby Petito's parents allege that Brian Laundrie's parents knew about their daughter's death along with the location of the crime
Dec 2, 2023
Jeremy is 5’11, weighs 245 lbs., has brown hair that is greying, green eyes and a greying beard
Dec 1, 2023
Jovannie Vega is accused of picking up the little boy and slamming him down onto the floor multiple times
Dec 1, 2023
'I feel bad for the families because I know exactly what they're going through,' said Mark Jacobo, whose son was killed in a firearm incident
Dec 1, 2023