MEAWW.COM / NEWS / CRIME & JUSTICE

Was child-like doll at Rex Heuermann's home a trophy? Social media chilled by eerie discovery

A child-sized doll, fair-haired and captivating, was found within the confines of a large wooden and glass case

LONG ISLAND, NEW YORK: In the quiet coastal town of Massapequa Park, Long Island, the community was rocked by the arrest of Rex Heuermann, a local architect accused of being the Gilgo Beach serial killer. As investigators delved into his life, an eerie discovery unfolded. On a seemingly ordinary Saturday morning, July 15, law enforcement officials descended upon Heuermann's childhood home, an aged and rundown house that held secrets waiting to be unveiled.

Amidst the chaotic scene, an unusual item caught the attention of investigators. A child-sized doll, fair-haired and captivating, was found within the confines of a large wooden and glass case. With gloved hands, two investigators carefully transported the doll from the dilapidated house to an awaiting police vehicle. Photos captured the haunting image of the doll: its blonde hair braided and adorned with a red bow, dressed in a red outfit, and posed within the case, which bore intricate flower carvings.

Searching for clues

News of the doll's discovery spread like wildfire, leaving the community in shock. Law enforcement officials, tight-lipped about their findings, were observed meticulously sifting through Heuermann's home for any shred of evidence that could shed light on his alleged crimes. A police source, speaking to the New York Post, stated, "We're just going through his house looking to see if there's any evidence. If he has any trophies." The doll was among the boxes of items removed from the house, alongside cat food, a cat scratch pole, a framed picture, and an empty bookcase.

Equipped with hazmat suits, gloves, and head coverings, investigators painstakingly filled blue bins with various items from the home. The solemn procession continued as they emptied the bins into a waiting truck, their movements deliberate and methodical. The doll, a chilling presence among the other possessions, remained an enigma—an unexpected twist in an already sinister tale. “Having that doll in the case may be some sort of pattern, maybe had some sort of fetish. He was gravitating to the sex workers,” Mike Akcazar, a professor at John Jay College of Criminal Justice, told PIX 11.

'Is it creepy? Yeah'

Social media platforms erupted with a flurry of reactions as news of the doll's discovery reached the public. Users, captivated by the mystery, shared their theories and thoughts on the bizarre find. One Twitter user mused, "Lots of speculation about the doll removed from the home of #RexHeuermann. Is it creepy? Yeah. Is it a trophy from the #Gilgo4 memorial sites? Who knows?" Another individual contemplated, "Did the Serial Killer leave Time-Out Dolls at the victims' crosses? Very, very creepy," accompanied by a compilation of images depicting dolls placed upon crosses.

Amidst the speculation, an unsettling connection was made. Following the discovery of the Gilgo Four's remains, it was alleged that someone had left child dolls at their memorials. The question arose: Could Rex's doll be a twisted souvenir, a chilling token of his dark deeds? Others voiced their discomfort, with one commenting, "If I'm honest, I find the arsenal of guns in #RexHeuermann's home less disturbing than the child-size doll."

As the investigation unfolded, further unsettling artifacts emerged from Heuermann's residence. Gloved officers, accompanied by the ever-watchful gaze of the media, removed a series of items that sent shivers down the community's collective spine. Among the haul was a portrait, seemingly ripped from a macabre nightmare. The painting depicted a blond woman's face, her eyes darkened by bruising, suggesting a haunting and troubling history. The battered visage intrigued onlookers and investigators alike.

Inside the mind of the suspected serial killer

Suffolk County Police Commissioner Rodney Harrison shed some light on the unnerving discoveries, describing Heuermann's childhood home as "a very cluttered house." Harrison revealed that the suspect had displayed tendencies akin to a "pack rat," leading investigators to scour every inch for potential trophies—mementos from his alleged slaughters. Authorities expanded their search, examining an Amityville storage unit linked to Heuermann, hoping to uncover additional evidence or human remains.

As the investigation intensified and public speculation reached a fever pitch, Rex Heuermann, a 59-year-old married father of two, continued to maintain his innocence. Arrested and charged with first- and second-degree murder in connection with three women whose bodies were found along Ocean Parkway, Heuermann vehemently denied any involvement. During a court appearance, he whispered to his lawyer, "I did not do this," his voice barely audible over the weight of suspicion and the chilling artifacts found in his possession.

That said, the discovery of the child-like doll in Heuermann's home has left the community of Massapequa Park reeling. It served as a macabre reminder of the horrors lurking in their midst. With each meticulously collected piece of evidence, investigators hope to unravel the truth and understand the mind of the suspected serial killer.