'The Bachelor' is using a 90s trend to bond its contestants to Peter Weber, should you follow suit?

From Sydney Hightower's bullying story to Kelsey's family issues, the show has implied that these stories help the couple bond better but is it really okay to ram in all that baggage right off the bat?
PUBLISHED FEB 17, 2020
Victoria Paul with Peter Weber (ABC)
Victoria Paul with Peter Weber (ABC)

Right from the time model and pageant girl, Victoria Paul revealed that she had a pretty harsh past, we've seen this season of 'The Bachelor' riddled with stories of past trauma.

From Sydney Hightower's bullying story to Kelsey's family issues, the show has implied that these stories help the couple bond better but is it really okay to ram in all that baggage right off the bat? Clever editing or not (Sydney's claims that she never got to go to prom has been debunked by fans), it does appear that the contestants really believe that sharing their past is a way to secure their future with lead Peter Weber. But is it healthy and should you follow suit in real life?

We asked a relationship expert to explain. 

"In real life, I wouldn't suggest this," said New York-based relationship expert Susan Winter, confirming that it isn't the brightest idea to go an emotional vomit session. "The first date isn't the time to unload a litany of emotional and psychological baggage. Though it may look like 'sharing,' it's actually a self-indulgent form of false depth."

This season has probably been slammed more than any other season of the very successful show in a while and one of the biggest reasons is its need to make it appear "genuine and real". It is, of course, a tried and tested formula and has worked for this show and its counterpart 'The Bachelorette'. However, this strategy has fallen short this season. It could be because this approach to relationship bonding is quite outdated. 

Calling it a very 90's trend, she said, "It was a trend in the 1990s to reveal ALL on the first date; drug addiction, alcoholism, sexual molestation, etc. The thought was that 'the better you know my wounds, the more closely we'll bond.' Too much, too soon, is dangerous." The testament to this is the fact that there have been barely any couples out of Bachelor Nation who have actually found a forever love in the person who gets the last rose. 

So what do you do then, just not talk about it at all? Because everyone has a backstory and some people do have enormous hardships. And of course, you have to get to know each other on more than just a superficial level. Just relax and roll with it, she says and don't blab without thinking.

"Assessing the appropriate pace to reveal deeply personal information requires diplomacy and tact. You don't want to hide the truth from your partner, but you also don't want to scare them off," advised Winter, "The revelation of these hardships should be organic and flow In a natural sense that acknowledges pace, timing, and appropriateness." Clearly it works to spice up a show, but your life, not so much.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Larry David’s latest HBO project mixes American history with awkward humor, surprise guest stars, and even a cameo from Barack Obama.
6 hours ago
A peaceful yoga practice hides a disturbing reality as a new docuseries exposes the real scandal tied to a controversial spiritual movement.
6 hours ago
'The Madison' stars Michell Pfeiffer and Kurt Russell in the leading roles of Stacy and Preston Clyburn, the heads of a wealthy family from Manhattan
19 hours ago
The horror limited series ‘Something Very Bad Is Going to Happen’ is created by Haley Z. Boston, directed by Weronika Tofilska of 'Baby Reindeer' fame.
21 hours ago
Season 4 of Tulsa King will also feature Terence Winter as the head writer and executive producer along with Ron Burkle, David Hutkin, and Thomas Kelly.
21 hours ago
The cast of the upcoming 'Baywatch' reboot will be led by Stephen Amell's Hobie Buchannon, who is a Baywatch Captain.
22 hours ago
Among other questions, 'The Pitt' still needs to answer whether charge nurse Dana will return for her next shift, and the ultimate fate of Baby Jane Doe.
22 hours ago
Season 3 of the AMC vampire drama 'The Vamprie Lestat' is adapted from Anne Rice's 1985 book of the same name.
1 day ago
Labrinth composed the music for Season 3 of 'Euphoria' after earning widespread acclaim for his work on the last two seasons of the HBO drama.
1 day ago
After a SAG Awards meet-up, Michael B. Jordan’s sudden social media activity has fans wondering if something bigger is brewing in the industry
1 day ago