'I don't buy that': ‘The Bachelor’ alum Ashley Ianconetti calls Gerry Turner and Theresa Nist's split 'baffling'

Ashley Ianconetti mentioned that she had always sensed something missing in the Golden Bachelor couple's relationship
PUBLISHED APR 13, 2024
Ashley Ianconetti calls Gerry-Theresa split 'BS' (Instagram/ @theresanist, @ashleyianconettihaibon)
Ashley Ianconetti calls Gerry-Theresa split 'BS' (Instagram/ @theresanist, @ashleyianconettihaibon)

NEWPORT, RHODE ISLAND: Ashley Iaconetti, a former contestant on 'The Bachelor' and 'Bachelor in Paradise,' made a subtle jab at the recent decision of 'Golden Bachelor' stars Theresa Nist and Gerry Turner to split just three months after tying the knot.

When asked for her opinion on the short-lived marriage, considering her journey as a Bachelor alum who found love and got married on the show, Ashley candidly shared her opinion, describing their decision to split as "bullsh**."

Ashley found the reason for Theresa and Gerry's split baffling, stating that their inability to decide on where to live didn't sit well with her. She expressed the belief that a couple truly in love would be willing to commute or find other ways to keep their relationship alive, regardless of the challenges posed by distance or differing living preferences.

"I think a a lot of what they said in GMA interview was 'BS' because you just dint say we still love each other and get divorced. You just don't," she said. "If it's a distance thing, at their age, live in Indiana, live in New Jersey. Visit each other once or twice a month. Be in love with each other, be married, just commute," she continued. " I don't buy that moving thing is the reason why they decided to split in three months after their marriage," she added. 

Ashley also mentioned that she had always sensed something missing in the Golden Bachelor couple's relationship. Having been invited to their wedding, she believed she had gained some insight into their dynamic and noticed elements that appeared lacking or incomplete.

Why did Gerry Turner and Theresa Nist split?

During their emotional interview on Friday, April 12, Turner disclosed that he and Nist had engaged in numerous heartfelt conversations about their relationship. They carefully examined their living arrangements and ultimately decided to end their marriage.

"We just feel like it’s best for the happiness of each of us to live apart," Turner expressed. "I still love this person. There’s no doubt in my mind," she added. Throughout the interview, they held hands and acknowledged that they were both still seeking love, although not with each other.

The reality TV personalities made an appearance on "Good Morning America," where they revealed their decision to divorce. They pointed to their disagreement over a place to live as the primary reason for their choice. Despite their efforts, they couldn't resolve this issue, leading to the conclusion that things weren't working out between them.

'The Golden Bachelor' contestant Theresa Nist
'The Golden Bachelor' contestant Theresa Nist and Gerry Turner end their marriage (ABC)

Did Theresa Nist and Gerry Turner have a prenup?

In an interview with Good Morning America on Friday, April 12, Gerry and Theresa revealed that they have a prenuptial agreement in place and strongly recommend it to others. This decision was made because they both had acquired various assets and salaries before getting married. 

After the split, Theresa had to part ways with her $40,000 diamond ring. Reflecting on this, she mentioned, "I think that’s the rule, I think I have to give this ring back. Sad to say." Gerry added, "But, you know what, we don’t have to give back the memories."

Gerry Turner and Theresa Nist to have a non-religious wedding (Instagram/@theresa_nist)
Gerry Turner and Theresa Nist had a prenup (Instagram/@theresa_nist)

Are Ashley Ianconetti and Jared Haibon still together?

Ashley Iaconetti and Jared Haibon are still happily together and married. They got engaged shortly after announcing their romantic relationship and exchanged vows in August 2019.

In late January 2022, they welcomed their first child, a son named Dawson Dimitri Brady Haibon. Currently, they are eagerly anticipating the arrival of their second child together. The couple resides in Rhode Island, where they operate Audrey's Coffee House & Lounge.

Ashley and Jared are still together (Instagram/ Ashleyianconettihaibon)
Ashley and Jared are still together (Instagram/ Ashleyianconettihaibon)
RELATED TOPICS THE BACHELOR (2002)

MORE STORIES

Jeff Jenkins, an executive producer of the show, teased that a new cast member will join the MomTok influencers in season 4
6 hours ago
Appearing on a recent episode of 'Call Her Daddy', Mark Ballas also spoke about how his injuries might affect his decision
8 hours ago
A thrilling finale crowns the Season 34 champion, but the truth about what the winner actually earns might be the season’s biggest twist.
13 hours ago
The 'Dancing With The Stars' 2026 live tour has added several finalists from season 34 to its star-studded line-up
1 day ago
The Olympic gold medalist was joined by a Grammy-nominated singer for her freestyle performance
1 day ago
'DWTS' judge Carrie Ann Inaba responded to a disrespectful comment by an audience member during the show's season 34 finale
1 day ago
A TikTok user claimed that Alix Earle and Val Chmerkovskiy's fandom has spiraled out of control, with fans creating fake accounts for votes
1 day ago
'DWTS' Season 34 finale wrapped up with intense competition and stellar performances
1 day ago
'Dancing with the Stars' Season 34 reached a milestone with its finale on Tuesday, November 25
1 day ago
Witney Carson took to TikTok and shed light on the wildlife conservationist's injury and how it will affect their final performances
2 days ago