Chicago P.D. finale shocker: Showrunner Rick Eid breaks down S05 tragic exit as #JusticeForAl trends on Twitter

The finale titled "Homecoming" not only sealed the fate of Detective Olinsky, a character brought to life since season 1 by Elias Koteas, but also ended up being hard on Voight.
Elias Koteas (Getty Images)
Elias Koteas (Getty Images)

In more ways than ever, that tragic conclusion to the fifth season of NBC's Chicago P.D. left fans and followers of the show heartbroken. The finale (episode 22) titled "Homecoming" not only sealed the fate of Detective Alvin Olinsky, a character brought to life since season 1 by Elias Koteas, but also ended up being quite toll-taking for his partner Voight (Jason Beghe). Tensions run high as Intelligence seeks justice for Olinsky after he's stabbed in prison.

In the last week itself, it became evident that Olinsky is up for some trying times. Although his bud Voight appeared to be trying his best to clear his name from the case - after all, his DNA was discovered on Bingham's body - and prove that he is innocent; ultimately the events culminates into one tragic twist for the fan-favorite detective. 

While in the prison, Olinsky is brutally attacked and stabbed numerous times, and all for a crime, he didn't even commit.


As it turns out, despite the best efforts, the detective's chances of surviving the sudden and unexpected attack are close to zero and it doesn't take more than a few minutes into Wednesday night's episode (May 9) for our greatest fears to come true. 

With Olinsky's death, the NBC drama also bid goodbye to long-time cast member Koteas - a move that fans of the show were clearly not anticipating. No sooner had the tragic exit been portrayed than fans flooded Twitter with #JusticeForAl.

However, if showrunner Rick Eid's words are to be believed then the decision to kill off the character was not sudden, but made over time. 

"He didn’t have to die. It was one of the things that just evolved from the storytelling this season. It was one of those ideas that the writers, after pitching, once that Woods-Voight-Olinsky story line really became front and center and we started thinking of ways to dramatize it and play it through to its honest conclusion, it was an idea that just kept coming up," the Chicago P.D. boss told Entertainment Weekly. 

"From a dramatic point of view, we all thought it was really interesting. From a human in real life point of view and a business point of view, we all thought it was really difficult and horrible. It was just a tough thing," he added. 

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Helaena’s visions connect her children, Dreamfyre and the Dragonpit to the deaths still ahead, with many fans left wondering about her fate.
1 hour ago
'Lioness' Season 3 follows the ongoing operations of the Lioness program, expanding its covert missions and personal stakes.
2 hours ago
‘Lioness’ Season 3 has officially begun, here's the full release schedule, episode dates, streaming times, and the finale's arrival date.
5 hours ago
The 'Gabby's Dollhouse' Season 14 trailer introduces a new character first teased in the 2025 film adaptation
7 hours ago
‘Tulsa King’ Season 4 gets a major creative update as the writer behind its acclaimed first season returns ahead of the show’s next chapter.
8 hours ago
Sheepstealer’s fate in Episode 7 of ‘House of the Dragon’ Season 3 leaves fans with big questions. Here’s what ‘Fire and Blood’ suggests.
9 hours ago
Previous episodes revealed that both Aegon and Sunfyre were burnt during the Battle at Rook's Rest
10 hours ago
After a dangerous Ukraine mission, Joe was attacked by two men at her home, which resulted in an unexpected situation.
13 hours ago
Alicent comes to Harrenhal with the intention of fulfilling Rhaenyra's wishes and reunites with her son Aemond as well as Alys
13 hours ago
DC's 'Booster Gold' series has made headlines again after years of development. Here's what the latest update means for the project.
2 days ago