‘She sucks as a judge’: ‘The Voice’ Season 24 fans call out Reba McEntire over Noah Spencer’s elimination

During the November 23 Playoffs episode, Reba McEntire had to choose only three members of her team for the Live Shows
UPDATED NOV 29, 2023
Internet slams 'The Voice' Season 24 judge Reba McEntire for not choosing contestant Noah Spencer (Instagram/@reba, @noahspencersmusic)
Internet slams 'The Voice' Season 24 judge Reba McEntire for not choosing contestant Noah Spencer (Instagram/@reba, @noahspencersmusic)

UNIVERSAL CITY, CALIFORNIA: 'The Voice' Season 24 judge Reba McEntire is currently at the receiving end of backlash due to Noah Spencer's eviction.

For those unaware, during the November 23 Playoffs episode of the singing reality show, the country music legend had to choose only three members of her team for the Live Shows.

Unfortunately, one of the contestants eliminated during the episode was none other than Noah Spencer. Fans expressed their discontent with Reba's decision to let go of Noah.

One social media user wrote, "Reba…WTF are you thinking? The nails…bad choice. And not picking Noah…really really bad choice. 💀👎🏼."

Another one penned, "Not picking Noah was a big mistake. He deserved the spot over Ruby. He is a diamond in the rough. Too bad he didn’t end up on another team. He deserved to go to the finals for sure."

A critic noted, "Reba, How did you not pick Noah??? He and Jordan shone the most and showed originality. Noah should be in the top contenders. Sad that he isn’t."

Followed by a user who commented, "Reba sucks as a judge."

A person chimed in, "There may be a market for the “old soul” but this is the Voice. You should be looking for new, original talent. #noah should have gotten the opportunity. He has so much potential."


 
 
 
 
 
View this post on Instagram
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

A post shared by NBC's The Voice (@nbcthevoice)


 

Team Reba's singer Tom Nitti leaves 'The Voice' Season 24 due to personal reasons

'The Voice' Season 24 contestant Tom Nitti who was a part of Team Reba had to leave the singing show due to some personal reasons. 

During the Monday, November 27, episode, McEntire revealed that Nitti made an offscreen exit from the show.

She told the cameras, "I have wonderfully talented people, but Tom had to leave for personal reasons, so I only have five artists tonight."

Then, Nitti took to his Instagram page and shared a post to explain his absence from the show.

He wrote, "Well, I’ve been dreading this day ever since the blind audition so here goes nothin’. …First and foremost I’m blessed beyond belief and I can’t say enough how much I love and appreciate the constant support from my fans, my friends and my family."

Tom continued, "As much as it absolutely stings to say, I had to make probably one of the hardest yet easiest decisions ever and ultimately at the end of the day, my kids will always come first and if I had to make the same decision again I’d do it over and over…." 


 
 
 
 
 
View this post on Instagram
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

A post shared by Tom Nitti (@tomnittimusic)


 

Who are the 3 remaining singers on Team Reba?

Reba McEntire squashed rumors of her accidental death back in 2012 (Tyler Golden/NBC)
Reba McEntire's final three singers are Rainer, Roar, and Leigh  (Tyler Golden/NBC)

Despite Tom's eviction, the five contestants of Team Reba, Ruby Leigh, Jordan Rainer, Jacquie Roar, Noah Spencer, and Ms Monet, amazed the judges as well as fans with their powerful performances. 

After all the performances, Reba had to make the big call of picking three contestants for the Live Shows.

The 'Fancy' singer ended up selecting Rainer, Roar, and Leigh as her final three for 'The Voice’ Top 12 live show.

'The Voice' Season 24 mentor Reba McEntire mocked for flirting with 19-year-old Tanner Massey in Playoffs

In a recent episode of 'The Voice' Season 24, Reba tried to flirt with the 19-year-old Tanner Massey.

Reba told Tanner, "Have I told you today that you're cute as a button," to which Tanner responded, "You know I think you did."

Then, John Legend mocked Reba by repeating her compliment and saying, "Have we told you, you're cute as button, Have we told you?" 

Niall Horan chimed in, "And as Reba would say 'I was taken to pieces.'"

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Brooks Rosser has made a name for himself throughout his auditions, the Ohana Round and the Disney Aulani round in 'American Idol' Season 24.
7 hours ago
The ‘Summer House’ spinoff, ‘In The City,’ is set to premiere on May 19, featuring Amanda Batula, West Wilson, and Kyle Cooke, with additional cast members.
17 hours ago
Star Lindsay Hubbard took to her IG story to quash all rumors of a potential reunion filming date
22 hours ago
Another hopeful exits 'American Idol' Season 24 after a tough competition in the 'Judges Song Contest' theme, after reaching the Top 12.
1 day ago
Connor Tomlinson exits ‘Love on the Spectrum’ after a standout run, teasing a bold career shift as the show moves on with new faces and fresh love stories.
1 day ago
Last season's Disney Night saw Lin-Manuel Miranda mentor the contestants ahead of their performances
1 day ago
The latest episode of the competition saw past winners return for an epic sing-off in the 'All-Star Showdown'
1 day ago
A fan-favorite’s comeback ends abruptly as delayed results shake the stage, leaving ‘American Idol’ viewers stunned.
1 day ago
Last week's results were delayed after the show received an unusually high number of votes
1 day ago
An unexpected hiccup with vote-counting delayed the elimination announcement in the last episode
1 day ago