'Dancing With The Stars' season 28: Shocked fans claim James Van Der Beek and Emma were 'robbed' after seeing their low scores

James has been a frontrunner ever since his debut performance, and this week even though his performance was great, he didn't receive the score he deserved. 
PUBLISHED OCT 8, 2019

'Dancing With The Stars' season 28 returned on Monday night and while fans congratulated James Van Der Beek as he and his wife are expecting their sixth child, they weren't happy with the scores he received from the judges. 

The actor who already has five kids with his wife Kimberly Brook revealed during the pre-taped segment that he and his wife are expecting their sixth child. Supported by his growing family, James and his pro partner Emma danced quickstep to the song 'Walking On Sunshine' and it was nothing but rainbows and roses, seeing the duo dance on stage. 

James has been a frontrunner ever since his debut performance, and this week though his performance was great, he didn't receive the score he deserved. 

James and Emma danced to 'Walking on Sunshine'. (ABC/Eric McCandless)

After his performance, James was treated to positive reviews from judges who revealed he was flawless and they had to dig deeper to criticize his performance. Complimenting the choreography Len Goodman said, "Sometimes my scores don't reflect my feelings. I think you're a great dancer." He also added the duo had great movement. 

Despite the amazing remarks the duo got from the judges and guest judge Leah Remini, in the end, James and Emma ended up getting 7 from each judge. Post James' performance, fans took to social media to reveal their disappointment with the scores this week claiming the actor deserved more than 7. 

Taking to Twitter a fan wrote, "Scored way too low for this dance. It seems the score scale is not consistent for each couple." Adding to that another fan said, "Does anyone else think those scores were way too low? He's the best dancer on the show and his happiness really shown through this week." 

Shocked a fan wrote, "7’s?? No way! He’s the best dancer on the show." While another said "They were robbed! Much better than scores showed!" 

Will James face elimination with these low scores? 'Dancing With The Stars' season 28 airs every Monday night only on ABC. Check your local listings for more information. 

RELATED TOPICS DANCING WITH THE STARS (DWTS)

GET THE BIGGEST CELEBRITY & ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

The 11-episode season premieres January 21, 2026 and can be streamed on Hulu and Disney+
31 minutes ago
McDermitt will be part of a storyline surrounding a new recurring cast member, Alona Tal.
3 hours ago
The Academy Award winner has been missing from the small screen since his 'Yellowstone' exit
5 hours ago
'Heated Rivalry' Episode 3 brings a new romance to the ice and a secret that could shake everything in the show
5 hours ago
HBO's new series, 'Heated Rivalry', follows two rival hockey players who end up falling in love
6 hours ago
On the lawless frontier, two unstoppable women clash over land, love, and survival and no one will emerge unscathed.
8 hours ago
A flyer to the musical, 'Oklahoma!', in a 'Stranger Things' Season 5 episode may be connected to Venca's origin story
10 hours ago
A desperate rescue plan collides with a dangerous cartel uprising and Kingstown may not survive the fallout.
10 hours ago
LEGO dropped a highly detailed 2,593-piece Creel House from ‘Stranger Things’, and while collectors love the design, the price has everyone talking
10 hours ago
Regé-Jean Page wooed hearts worldwide with his captivating portrayal of the Duke of Hastings on 'Bridgerton'
11 hours ago